Monster Tooth Fairy Pillow

This post and its photos may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon associate I earn from qualifying purchases. If you make a purchase through these links, I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Today I’m sharing the Monster Tooth Fairy Pillow I made for Connor.

He lost his first tooth a few weeks ago and you’d think I would have made him one as soon as he told me to feel his loose tooth. But nope, not me. I waited until the day his tooth fell out.

Luckily it didn’t take long to whip up and I’m now officially the coolest mom in the world!

I used inexpensive felt and a few buttons so this project is cheap and easy. I even created a free printable pattern to make this project even easier for you.

Materials needed:

3 pieces of green felt
1 piece of orange felt
1 piece of light blue felt
1 piece of white felt
2 large buttons
embroidery thread
needle
liquid stitch
polyester fiberfill

Step 1: Download the pattern HERE.

Step 2: Trace the pattern on the felt and cut out the two sides of the pillow. Then cut out the bottom half of the tooth for the the pocket.

Step 3: Cut out the two circles for the eyes and the teeth.

Step 4: Glue the teeth to the back of the pocket and glue the circles on to the front of the pillow.

Step 5: Sew the buttons to the front of the circles for the eyes.

Step 6: Lay all the three pieces together so the pocket is on top. Stitch around the entire pillow (make sure you leave a small section open) using the embroidery thread and needle.

Step 7: Stuff your pillow with the fiberfill and finish sewing.